All things equal, I'd take the Gerbing jacket. There just seems to be more to it. It's thicker and seems to be a little better made. But I've had to return my fair share of Gerbing products..jacket 2X, gloves 3X, socks 1X. I bought the Hotwired jacket, pant liners, insoles and gloves on sale. Don't recall what I paid but I did end up returning the gloves a few weeks later because I couldn't deal with the loss of dexterity. I really like the idea of having the controller built into the gloves. Hopefully they will redesign the gloves some day and make them a little thinner. Since all things are not equal (price and warranty), I highly recommend the hotwired stuff.